Ultimately, I believe we all teach ourselves.
Taking classes can be helpful because it can help motivate you and give you a structure, removing barriers to practice. But you need to be actively engaged. Just turning up doesn’t guarantee you’ll make any progress.
How effective a class is will also depend on how well it meets the criteria for effective learning.
If you understand what makes for effective learning yourself, you’ll be perfectly capable of constructing your own practice exercises, tailor made for the skills you particularly want to improve. In fact, I’d recommend that you do. Because taking control of your own learning will help you make much more progress in the long run.
It will also transform your life. I really mean that. The self-confidence that comes from making progress towards your artistic goals under your own steam is self-perpetuating. The more you learn, the more you realise that you can learn. You can’t spend you’re entire life in art courses (unless you’re substantially better off than me) so figuring out how to drive your own learning forwards is the only way you’re going to make real progress in the long run.
(Agree? Disagree? Let me know in the comments.)
Understanding what makes effective learning is really going to help you take control of your artistic development. For that, you need to know something about how we learn.
How do we learn?
Quite simply, learning is brain change. I don’t mean that metaphorically. It’s actual, physical change in your brain.
Thankfully, some very clever brain scientists have spent the last twenty years or so learning about how change happens in the brain. What they’ve discovered applies to any kind of learning. So it applies to us artists, too.
Brain science can help us get better at art.
In order to be really effective, our learning activity needs to meet some important criteria. There are three that stand out in all the brain science and learning literature I’ve read.
What three things make practice more effective?
- Your practice needs to be enjoyable. This might seem obvious. We don’t learn much when we’re bored. The science behind this is that the changes we make in our brains through our learning activities are just temporary at first. It takes something more to make them stick. Our brain has to care about the changes enough to decide to save them permanently. It does that through the release of chemicals (people in white coats call them “neuromodulators”) which help make the changes permanent. Enjoying what the activity we’re engaged in helps the release of these chemicals. So make your practice fun.
How to do it: I think we’re pretty lucky here because drawing is inherently enjoyable. That’s why we do it. I mean, it’s not like we’re learning accountancy here. If you don’t enjoy making your art, there’s something wrong with your approach. You’re probably pushing yourself too hard. Maybe you’re suffering from a case of destructive perfectionism.
- You need to be paying attention. The brain needs to think this change is important or it won’t be saved. More of those useful chemical neuromodulators are released when the brain is “switched on”.
How to do it: Don’t practice when you’re tired, it’s not efficient. Practice when you’re alert and firing. Practice regularly in short bursts, so you stay fresh. That’s much more effective that a big block once a week.
- You need to be stretching yourself. If you’re idling through your practice, the changes won’t happen in the first place. Work constantly at a level just beyond what you find it easy. If you don’t have to try, you won’t be making any progress and may as well not bother.
How to do it: If you’re not making mistakes, you’re not trying hard enough. Recognise when you’re coasting. If you find your mind wandering as you practice, try making the exercise a little harder. Add some complication. Make it just hard enough that you have to concentrate in order to do it at all.
How does this work in practice?
Here’s a few examples of design and composition examples from Creative Triggers art practice community. All of these exercises are designed to contain elements of the three criteria for effective learning.
Breathing lines
What it is: It’s simply this: Draw a series of vertical lines across your paper, in any medium you choose. Breathe in on a down stroke, out on an up stroke. Make them as evenly spaced and straight as you possibly can.
Here’s an example from a couple of years ago, when I first started to do this exercise as part of my regular practice:
Pretty ropey!
Here’s another version from a couple of weeks ago. The method has changed somewhat, the strokes are all down strokes and the lines are too long and drawn too slowly to be able to do them in a single exhalation (you’d asphyxiate!). Hopefully you can see some improvement…
This exercise is calming, meditative and inherently pleasant. Although it looks almost trivial at first glance, most people find it has hidden depths once they try it. It also makes a great warm-up to a drawing session.
In terms of stretching yourself, this exercise is almost endless, because you can always improve your manual dexterity. You can try it with various media, too. Usually we start with pencil, graduate to charcoal, and finish with Chinese brush and ink – which is extremely difficult! It’s up to you not be complacent, to strive always for just a little better.
Here’s a short demo video I made of it a couple of years ago:
Corner ornament
What it is: Take a right angle. Now add a third line to transition between the two, making a triangle. Now design an ornament that fits that triangle, and does the job more beautifully.
Here’s an early, simple example. Simple ones like this are good at first, the simplicity allows you to concentrate on the spacing and the quality of the marks more.
Here’s a more recent version. The design is more complex, more creative, but hopefully you can also see some improvement in the spacing and proportion, and the quality of the line.
Creating a beautiful design is relaxing and enjoyable. The end result, if you make a good one, is very satisfying. That’s the kind of reward that will help persuade your brain that the learning is important and worth storing permanently. And you can always do a better version of the design you just made – a more balanced design, a better and more beautiful line. A great way to approach this is to refine a design by tracing, changing a few things to try to improve the balance.
Negative space design
What it is: Make an accurate, line only drawing from life, or from a reference, of a simple subject. Flowers are great for this. Now trace the outer contour only, with no internal lines. Now take two pieces of card, cut to form right angles, and use them to frame the drawing, making a crop of it. Move the card border around to create a crop of the original drawing you like. Trace the crop to make a composition.
Once you’ve found a crop you like, refine it. Change the design, try to improve it. Try to make the line more beautiful, the spacing better. It’s this process of constant refining and improving that keeps you at the cutting edge of what you can do. Not every refinement will be an improvement. You will make mistakes, if you’re doing it right. Learn from them.
Here’s an example of a design taken from a simple drawing of lily buds, developed and refined over time. There were a lot of intermediate drawings too, some more successful, some less. Throughout this progression, and the progression of many these I’ve developed like this, my sense of design, sensitivity to spacing and composition has developed. The emphasis on gradual refinement has kept me pushing at the edges of what I’m capable of, making sure I’m constantly learning and improving.
Producing these kinds of drawing is fascinating. When we started producing them at Creative Triggers it really lit a fire under people. And our members created some really stunning designs this way. If you haven’t tried doing a negative space drawing, I recommend you do so.
Over to you
So if you want to have a go at creating your own exercise, make sure you build in the three elements of effective learning and you won’t go far wrong.
It’s a simple thing, creating a highly specific exercise like this. It’s a little thing to do it every day every day. The change it makes in your brain each day is small.
But over time, those little changes become permanent, and build up to be bigger ones – the kind of changes that represent real development in your sensitivity and skill, real progress towards your artistic goals.
And they may, quite possibly, change the course of your life.
Best wishes,
Paul
Posted: January 15th 2014
The Keys to Colour - Free 6 step email course
Learn how to:
- mix any colour accurately
- see the value of colours
- lighten or darken a colour without messing it up
- paint with subtle, natural colour
it’s ok. I am an instinct drawer, i’d never had a school. I paint with a lot of difficulties trying to the perspective only.My best shadows are in black and white drawings. so I take care your lessons about everything on art. my best wishes, severino.( I hope that my english is goodest than my art!)
Hi Severino,
Thanks for commenting. If you struggle with perspective, the best thing to do is get a decent book. It’s one of the few areas of art that can be learned without having to spend a lot of time practising I think, since it’s based on understanding of concepts, not skill development.
I’ve heard Norling’s “Perspective made easy” is good, you might try that one.
Thanks for the great article and tips!
Thanks Pamela, I hope you find it to be of some practical use.
I really enjoy your helpful tips and am having a good time working my way through the exercises in your Creative Triggers program. It is just right for me!
Thanks very much Marla, that’s great to hear 🙂
Hi, Just signed up for your site. I volunteer tutor Intermediate to Advanced Drawing to seniors and I am always looking for new ways to engage them (a couple have been with me for several years so I’ve got to stay ahead of them!) I will bring this session to the start of my new class and see if I get them to play along. We have fun every class and they certainly challenge me but I wouldn’t change a thing. Thanks for the information!!
Hi Paul,
I’d just like to say I’m in a life-drawing class and I’m not even too bothered about getting good teaching in the class as I am mainly concerned about having a live figure to draw.
Yes the class could be cheaper and if there was another way of getting cheap or even free models I’d take it.
Teaching is usually a few comments thrown in about what you should be doing in the drawing at a given point in time, which very often, given another ten minutes you were about to do anyway.
But, I’m not trying to sound arrogant there are times when I desperately need some advice. You do get stuck, confused, even desperate sometimes on a bad day.
I’ve never been to an art class that takes you from step 1 to step 10, they nearly all just chip in comments here and there.
The step 1 to 10 thing is more how you would be taught a computer program or how to bake a victoria sponge or something.
If you were being taught typography obviously you would have to go step by step, introducing ideas and materials. In fact I always find there is a jargon barrier. Every subject has its own long list of terms that you have to learn to be able to speak the language of that subject.
IT is so full of them and it always sounds like they were dreamed up by kids. Well compared with me, they are kids I suppose.
Also, classes allow you to meet people and cross fertilise ideas. Once again if there was a cheaper way of doing this I’d jump at it.
I once said I’d like to join an art club but there’s none in my area and the answer was, set one up then and run it. But you don’t always want to be on the stage; sometimes being in a seat, a few rows back in the stalls, feels fine.
All the best from
John Raines
Hi Paul,
Having read what I’ve just written, I realise I’m missing your whole point. That to learn something big and complicated it is best to break it down into smaller, simpler parts or units. When you get good at all the units you get good at the big and complicated as a result.
So in this note Paul I’m trying to show I have paid more attention to your invaluable lessons. I might have to device my own set of exercises that suit the topic of life drawing.
Definitely, the contour flower drawing could be included. This could lead to contour drawings of the life model.
Blocking in shapes only could lead to better composition of the figure within the format.
Maybe just doing small parts of the figure to get better at the individual parts, head, hands feet etc.
Thank you very much Paul, there always ideas to use and adapt in your work for us.
All the best
John Raines
Thanks John. Yes, that’s pretty much my approach to learning. Start with small steps, learn the individual skills well, and they will build up to something much bigger over time.
That said, having access to a live model is a perfectly good reason for going to a class!
Hi Rachael, I really hope those exercises do help you, and your students. Great that you teach on a voluntary basis. The world needs more like you.
Great article – love the message that taking responsibility for your learning and challenging yourself gains the results. Rest of article great too esp. negative space design.
Thank you.
You’re welcome Geraldine, I’m really glad to hear you enjoyed it.