You’ve heard the advice plenty of times.
Draw every day.
Just paint.
It would seem to make sense – except that it’s perfectly possible to do that and not get any better at all.
Or to make such slow progress that you can’t actually see it happening, which isn’t very inspiring either.
That may seem surprising but think about it: Many people drive every day but don’t actually get better at it. In fact, most of us get gradually worse!
Something like this happened to me, early on in my current learning journey, when I decided to stop painting and just draw for a year, so I could concentrate on values.
I set myself to draw 100 value studies.
And that’s the standard advice too: Concentrate on value, it’s the most important part of painting.
There is at least some truth to that. In any event that’s exactly what I did.
100 seemed like a lot when I came up with the number. It really did. I wasn’t sure I’d ever get to the end of that series.
This is the first one.
Some way in, I was beginning to see some progress. But it was slow, and I wasn’t seeing progress from drawing to drawing.
It became difficult to keep motivated and keep the series going. Very, very difficult.
But then something happened that turned that practice on its head.
I discovered Munsell.
(Cue choirs of angels and shining golden light, complete with cheesy voice-over: “and so a new day dawned, in which painters ceased to struggle with value and the world became filled with beautiful art…”)
Well, perhaps not. But it did change everything for the better.
What happened next made more difference to my understanding of value than all of the previous drawings I’d done in that series.
In fact, it made more difference to the quality of my painting than anything I’ve ever done before or since.
First, I practiced matching each of the values of the Munsell scale exactly. I mean, I was obsessive about it. If it was even a tiny bit out, I kept trying to get closer.
Then, when I could match the values exactly, on the advice of Graydon Parrish, I got 11 cubes and eleven spheres, and I painted 9 of them each one of the values of the Munsell value scale, and painted one black and one white. I did the same with 11 spheres.
Finally I did little paintings of each cube and sphere. Here’s an example.
Then a few with some real world objects too, of the same value as the cubes and spheres.
I worked out a way to accurately judge the values I was seeing on the cubes using a colour checker, like this.
By this time I was starting to get excited. I could already see that even though I was just painting with neutrals, I was already painting with a much higher level of realism – and also with more light, atmosphere and depth.
You can read all about that practice here:
Munsell Neutral Value Exercises, Part One
So I did maybe 20 or so little value studies in paint, maybe a few more. It was a while ago and my memory isn’t what it used to be š
The point is though, that after some of this very focused practice I went back to the value drawing series, with a new approach and a slightly different method.
And I found I’d gone from this:
To this:
Huge leap forward.
Why did I make so much more progress in such a short time, and from less work?
Because I was using a method that fitted with the most important principles of effective practice:
- Focus on one single skill in isolation from everything else – by painting cubes, I wasn’t trying to make a good picture. I wasn’t thinking about composition, whether I was making a nice piece of work, whether the subject was recognisable, any of that. I was just painting cubes, and I wasn’t trying to do anything except paint the values as accurately as I could.
- Get instant feedback. Because I had the colour checker to show me how I was doing, I could check on whether or not I was nailing the values. I had an independent means of checking my results without relying on my perception only.
Yes but practising is boring!
I know that some people will resist the idea of this kind of practice.
It seems unartistic. A bit too scientific, perhaps.
Just plain dull.
I get it, I do. But here’s the thing: If you want to make faster progress on specific skills, it doesn’t matter whether you’re a musician, a dancer, a surgeon, a sportsperson, or a painter, the principle is the same:
Practice is not performance. You need to practice.
If you just say you’re going to draw something every day, or “just paint”, that’s performance.
I’m not saying you won’t make progress, you may. But much more slowly than you could.
If you create a practice method for yourself and stick to it for a little while, you’ll see the progress start to happen very quickly.
If you just repeat what you already do, over and over, you’ll get very good at doing what you already do. And if you want to improve, then, by definition you need to be doing something you’re not doing now.
So what about workshops?
The reason I’m writing about this today is that I’ve just come back from Northern Ireland where I taught a 5 day workshop on colour, hosted by my friend Julie Douglas at the Belfast Academy of Realist Art.
I talked a lot about the difference between practice and performance when we were there. And I believe that’s particularly relevant at a workshop.
I can’t solve every colour struggle someone has in a 5 day workshop. I can’t really deepen someone’s understanding of colour that much in that time.
But what I can do is teach a method of practice that someone can take away and use to do all of that themselves.
I can show how effective the method is. And I can watch with delight as the light bulbs start to go on and people see it happen in their studies, realise they can nail any colour, get values right and create atmosphere, space and light.
That’s a really special experience for me, so much so that I’ve decided to start doing more workshops. So far I’ve only done three, and only two on colour. That’s going to change this year and next š
That’s also why I give away all the materials I use to teach this method when I teach a workshop, including the cube and spheres I bring as subjects for people to paint. Because what I’m teaching is a method of practice, because I think that’s how people will get the most benefit from their time there.
So ask yourself: what do you struggle with most?
This is my advice to you, assuming you want a more effective way to build your drawing and painting skills.
Pick one skill you want to get better at. It might be drawing accuracy. Judging the value of colours. Mixing a colour accurately. Balancing a composition.
Take that skill out in isolation from everything else, so that you’re not tempted to actually try and make a piece of work, so you’re not tempted to perform.
If you can, make sure you have a way to give yourself feedback on how well you’re doing, an independent check. It’s not always possible to do this since some of the skills we want to develop are aesthetic. But if you can, it will put your practice on steroids.
Then repeat this exercise for a while until you see some results.
I’m willing to bet you’ll see them more quickly than you’d think.
Yes but it’s not art is it?
Perhaps you’re thinking that art is about more than skill. That drilling skills won’t help you make more meaningful work, or find your voice, or communicate emotional depth.
Yes and no…
If you’re not struggling with basic skills (as let’s face it, the majority of artists are these days since those skills don’t get taught in mainstream education) then you’re free to devote your time and energy to exactly those things. The things that really matter to us.
I mean only to help.
If your lack of basic skills has you struggling every time you go to the easel, it will be much more difficult for you to make progress on the big stuff.
And you know, it isn’t even that hard to do.
One last thing
If you have a specific skill you’d like to develop, stick it in the comments, and I’ll see if I can come up with a way to break it down and turn it into an exercise that will help you build the skill.
Best wishes and thanks for reading
Paul
P.S. Click this link if you want to see the full series of still life drawings. I’m not sure that they’re all there, actually, or that they’re in the right order. But the most recent ones, done after the Munsell-aided value practice, are at the top.
The Keys to Colour - Free 6 step email course
Learn how to:
- mix any colour accurately
- see the value of colours
- lighten or darken a colour without messing it up
- paint with subtle, natural colour
Dear Paul,
I’ve written to you previously and all I can say is a huge Thank You once again for this latest post.
I teach at several institutions, privately run courses , Royal Hibernian Academy school, prisons etc. in Dublin.
Without getting too carried away with myself, (angelic music and deep cinematic voice over etc.) I can relate to the emphasis you put in your teaching on Practice vs Performance it is gospel.
I know, sounds a tad dramatic, but I’m sure you get my meaning.
I am going to direct my current and future students to your site.
I have been trying to explain a similar approach myself to my students, and often it does not sink in as quite a few of the participants just want a ‘product’ at the end of the course.
Anyway, I’m banging on a bit, so huge THANK YOU Paul, you are truly becoming Master.
I mean that not in a cheesy way but genuinely, as you probably know the story about the great cellist Pablo Casals when asked why he ‘the great master’ was still practicing in his 90’s he replied ‘so that I might get better at playing the cello’ .
All the very best,
Sean
Absolutely fabulous post, Paul.
Your clean analytical approach to understanding tone is refreshing. I did life drawing with Nerina Simi in Florence in the early 1980s, and although drawing the nude in charcoal 6 mornings a week for 2 years with 2 week poses, was teaching us tone, as well as anatomy and construction, I find your dissection down to the simple essentials a great and faster way of explaining the theory of tone.
Actually to be fair, the Signorina did explain in the painting still life room, the subtleties of tone, including making us aware of the “air” between one object and another!!
Practice. . .YESssss, and don’t be afraid to make mistakes.
Please keep up your good work, Paul.
Saluti dalla Toscana,
~Anne
Dear Paul,
Wonderful post! Iām anxious to get started! Can you give me some ideas how to practice composition and how to check my results?
Thank you for sharing your knowledge so freely.
āRose
Dear Paul,
I am an artist who deliberately practices. So, a million thank youās for validating my efforts. It may feel like self defeating, but itās really self discipline.
I set an objective to master a technique. After a while I realized that I was indeed making the same mistakes over and over againā¦until I decided on ādoing something youāre not doing nowā.
I achieved my objective and I can say that the method I settled on is unorthodox. Imagine that? In order to be in control, I had to be creative!
The one thing that drives me batty is accurately measuring pigment from the tube to mix different values. Itās always a messy, hit and miss affair.
Iām beginning to suspect and reluctantly accept that this is ājust the way it isā. Do you have a method or should I just get āover itā.
Respectfully,
Marie
Great article Paul! I did the exact same thing you did. I stopped painting and drew in charcoal for a year. It made a big difference for me. I can draw more accurately than I did before. This is how I ended up joining your threads community. I wanted to learn the Munsell Method when I started painting again. Iām definitely going to paint a series of value studies for daily painting challenge.
Love reading your posts and looking through your work, Paul! Enlightening! Thanks!
Picking one thing I’m weak at is so hard! I feel weak in all areas. š
Again, another brilliant post Paul, thank you. You have to do it, to get better at it. Your vision improves and your skills develop as you repeat. Neuroplasticity, hard wire those little neurons everyday to information and ability you desire.
My philosophy is to never give up and always start in the beginning.
Dear Paul,
Thank you for pointing so many of us in the direction of meaningful practice.
One question I have is where and how did you acquire your cubes and spheres to work with? Also I am here in the USA.
Thank you
You can get cubes, cylinders and spheres at Hobby Lobby, Michael’s and other crafty superstores, you just have to roam about since they’re often in unexpected aisles. Some of them are quite cheap in both senses of the word, so you need to see what they have and not necessarily buy the first-ones you find. Some are foam, others are cardboard or a paper-mache type molded “something”.
I painted mine in cheap store-brand artist acrylic primer-gray (dries faster) and then in acrylic color-paint. Next on my list of chores is re-painted at-least some spheres Paul’s recommended shades of Gray series.
Hi Paul,
Thanks for the interesting post. I primarily paint plein air watercolour. Areas I would like to improve are drawing accuracy (line) and brush control. Any suggestions gratefully received.
Thanks Neil
Hi Paul
Thanks a lot for your very useful post. Would you please advise a list of the skills one needs to become a good painter/artist. I mean not very general name of an skill ( say drawing ), I need a more detailed list.
Thanks, Reza
Yes! Please put on some more workshops – I would love to learn these skills!
I have the honor of teaching a group of 12 year olds who are interested in art this summer for one week. I am wondering what you think the most important skill would be to focus on?
What do you wish you learned when you were 12?
Thanks so much for all you do.
Pam
Paul,
I believe foundational skills in art are essential (and sorely lacking in US art schools and university programs).
This is why I am a huge proponent of the atelier training now being offered in realist academies worldwide.
Personally, I know I have no foundational skills; only bits picked up here and there, which are completely insufficient in becoming an accomplished artist.
Practice is not very effective if it doesn’t have any purpose and structure behind it, along with a great deal of discipline to see any progress.